Get home insurance that protects what you need
Standard home insurance doesn’t cover everything—floods, earthquakes, or coverage for valuable items like jewelry and art often require separate policies or endorsements. Switching over to a more customizable policy ensures you’re paying for what you really need. Use Money’s home insurance tool to find the right coverage for you.
SoFi: The S&P Snub Is a Feature — Not a Bug
For years, “fintech” meant razor-thin margins, growth-at-all-costs, and a reliance on hype cycles. “Digital banks” were promises, not businesses. And “platform finance” was usually a marketing angle, not a real structural business model.
Then came 2024–2025. And with it, a quiet transformation: SoFi Technologies went from promise to performance. It stopped being just a fintech upstart — it became a bank, a diversified financial platform, and increasingly, a modern consumer-finance utility built for scale.
Its latest results are proof: revenue hitting record highs, fee-based revenue more than doubling, member growth surging past 12 million, and profits quietly compounding.
And yet, in the latest S&P 500 index rebalance — where every institutional fund scrubs its watchlist, weights shift, and thousands of papers chase the same 450–500 names — SoFi was left out. From one angle, that feels like a snub. From another, it might be the most bullish thing that has happened to the stock in a long time.
Why Exclusion Right Now Could Be a Blessing
1. Avoiding forced flows and near-term volatility
Index inclusion is often treated as a one-way valve for stock price. But it can be a double-edged sword: inflows tend to come early and get front-loaded; then liquidity dries up fast, leaving holders stuck at peaks. By staying outside the index, SoFi avoids that structural reversion pressure.
Instead, the stock is free to compound based on fundamentals — loan growth, deposits, fee-based revenue, banking margins — rather than passive buying algorithms chasing weight adjustments.
2. More time to build real, durable earnings
SoFi isn’t just a loan-app company. It’s a fully chartered bank with deposit funding, interest spread income, and a diversified financial services stack. It recently launched a crypto-trading platform under its bank charter — the first nationally chartered bank to do so — blending traditional finance with modern consumer demand.
The firm also expects its tangible book value to increase materially — an indicator that capital strength is building, which could support further regulated-bank expansion or reinvestment.
Being outside the S&P for now gives management room to grow the balance sheet, prudently allocate capital, and deepen earnings quality — without the pressure to maximize quarterly EPS for index-driven inflows.
3. Optionality still compressed — big catalysts ahead
SoFi still checks many of the boxes for S&P inclusion: banking license, scale, diversified operations, profitability trend, and growing deposit base. Many analysts posit that inclusion will come — perhaps in 2026 — assuming continued execution.
Between now and then, the company may roll out new financial-product innovations, expand crypto/trading offerings, grow deposit volumes, and deepen fee-based revenue — creating upside without being tied to passive index flows.
For investors, this is optionality. It’s not leveraged. It is the difference between owning a business and owning a bet.
Strengths: What SoFi Gets Very Right
Multi-product platform + bank charter: loans, deposits, banking, investing, crypto — under one roof. That gives SoFi flexibility, scale, and margin diversification rarely seen in fintech.
Rapid growth + recurring revenue mix improving: Fee-based revenue growing quickly, reducing cyclicality of interest-rate cycles or credit cycles.
Profitability achieved and expanding: GAAP profitability sustained, margins improving, adjusted EBITDA strong.
Balance-sheet grounded in deposits: The deposit base gives stability, a natural hedge vs. cost of funds — and avoids over-reliance on wholesale funding or securitization cycles.
Regulatory advantage of a national bank + first-mover in crypto banking: The ability to offer traditional bank services plus crypto trading under one charter gives a unique value proposition that’s rare in 2025.
Risks & What Could Break This Thesis
Dilution risk & capital raises: The recent $1.5 billion stock offering — its second major raise in a short time — spooked investors and triggered a short-term drop in share price, raising concerns over dilution and capital-structure stress.
Competition & credit risk: Transitioning from fintech to full-blown bank brings legacy-style risks: loan defaults, interest-rate pressure, regulatory compliance, deposit competition.
Valuation expectations baked in: The bullish case now assumes execution is flawless and growth continues at an aggressive pace. A macro-driven credit slowdown or economic downturn could stress the loan book or slow consumer adoption, undermining the narrative.
Index timing risk: If S&P inclusion is delayed beyond 2026 or if SoFi grows too big and fails to meet other index filters (float, liquidity, volatility), the “optionality” may become stranded value — good business trapped outside passive demand.
SoFi Is Building, Index Doesn’t Matter (Yet)
SoFi is no longer a speculative fintech startup. It has matured into a genuine financial institution: a national bank + diversified financial-services platform + tech-enabled distribution. Its recent results show real scale, recurring revenue, deposit funding, profitability, and strategic optionality.
Not being in the S&P right now isn’t a weakness. It may be its greatest tactical advantage. It gives the company time — time to build capital, time to prove the business model, time to avoid forced flows, and time to launch the kinds of new financial products (crypto banking, all-in digital banking, embedded fintech) that materially increase valuation without external hype cycles.
For investors, this means there is still upside optionality with real underlying value — not just momentum or speculation. If you believe digital finance will continue to absorb more of the U.S. consumer wallet, if you believe deposit-funded banking with fintech cost structure can win, and if you believe SoFi can execute, then you don’t need S&P inclusion to justify ownership.
Because when the value is real, the index is just noise.
—
Education, not investment advice.
Sources: